Do Bandit Signs Work? Yard Signs vs. a Website: Real Cost Per Lead

If your lawn care, pressure washing, pool or window cleaning work comes off bandit signs, here's what each call really costs, next to real lead numbers from 3,000+ small business websites on Vibe Otter.

If you run a lawn care, pressure washing, pool, window cleaning, gutter, painting or junk removal business, you've probably done it: a stack of coroplast signs, a bundle of H-stakes, and a Saturday morning hitting every busy corner in town.

Signs work. Plenty of owners built their first route off them. But what does a call off a bandit sign actually cost you, and how does that stack up against a website?

We pulled together what owners have reported about their own signs on LawnSite, the WindowCleaner.com forum, the Pressure Washing Institute forum, Reddit and trade magazines, and put it next to our own numbers from more than 3,000 small business websites on Vibe Otter.

What bandit signs really cost

The going rate for a corrugated plastic yard sign bought in bulk is about $3. Across 15 bulk orders that owners and sign sellers reported, the median price was $2.99 a sign, and prices ranged from $0.89 to $5.25.

WhoTradeWhat they paidPer sign
Art Oliveri, Pressure Washing Institute forum, 2013Pressure washing"They cost a $130 for a 100 12x18's"$1.30
NJWashingGuy, Pressure Washing Institute forum, 2009Pressure washing / soft washing100 two-color, double-sided signs with stands "for about $525 delivered"$5.25
lawnguy01, LawnSite, 2013Lawn care"At 250 pcs, you shouldnt pay more than $2.25 each", stakes under $1$2.25 + stake
F&J Lawn Service, LawnSite, 2019Lawn care"100 single sided signs 12/18 for $89", no stakes$0.89
apsurfacesolutions, WindowCleaner.com, 2011Window cleaning"50 of them for $250.00"$5.00
UZ Marketing (sign seller), Reddit, 2024Sign seller"100 for $338 with stakes shipped to your door"$3.38

And that's just the sign. Stakes often cost extra, signs walk off, and some towns pull them and send you the bill:

"more than HALF of my signs were stolen or gone after just 2 days!!"
— GCPS, lawn care, Tampa area, LawnSite, 2019
"Around here the city sends a truck out once a month to pick them up, then you will get a $100 invoice in the mail for doing it."
— Km81, LawnSite, 2011
"Signs have a lifespan of about 3 days in the field"

How many calls do bandit signs get?

Here's every report we found where a service business owner said how many signs they put out and how many calls or leads came back:

WhoTradeSignsCalls / leads
DepartureRadiant4042, Reddit, 2024Gutter cleaning25about 15
Mike_Goeller, WindowCleaner.com, 2014Window cleaning89
Marrokal Design & Remodeling, JLC, 2013Remodeling (signs at past clients' homes)7540
Mark Scott, JLC, 2013Remodeling (signs at past clients' homes)482
ishabowa, Reddit, 2026Window cleaning1001
GCPS, LawnSite, 2019Lawn care250
WinCleanPlus, WindowCleaner.com, 2014Window cleaning1000
logicalguy11, Reddit, 2026Junk removal150
Total39667

Add it up and you get 67 calls from 396 signs. At that rate, it takes about 15 signs to get 2.5 calls.

Look at the spread, though. Three of the eight owners got zero calls, and one remodeler accounts for 40 of the 67. Signs can hit big or flop completely, and where you put them matters a lot.

Bandit signs vs. a website: cost per lead

Now the comparison. On the website side, we looked at our own platform: across the 3,000+ small business websites on Vibe Otter, a new website averages 2.5 submitted leads in its first month, and it costs $34.

To keep it fair, we count one website form submission the same as one phone call: one person asking you for a price. Neither one is a booked job yet. Here's what it takes to get 2.5 leads each way:

Bandit signsWebsite on Vibe Otter
Leads2.5 calls2.5 leads (first-month average)
What it takesAbout 15 signsOne month of your website
CostAbout $45 (15 signs at $2.99)$34
Cost per leadAbout $18 per call$13.60 per lead
Your timeAbout 3 hours to put out 15 signs around town24 minutes to build your site
Still working next month?Only the signs nobody pulledYes, as long as it's live

The math: 15 signs × $2.99 = about $45 for 2.5 calls, or about $18 per call. $34 ÷ 2.5 leads = $13.60 per lead.

The time: 24 minutes is the average time the owners in our 3,000+ site sample took to build their own site on Vibe Otter. For signs, figure about 3 hours to drive around town and put out 15 signs. And you do it again every time your signs get pulled. You build the website once.

Two more things the table leaves out. The 2.5 is form submissions only, so someone who finds your site and just taps your number to call isn't in that count. And the sign numbers don't include your stakes, your gas, your Saturday, or a city invoice.

People are already Googling your trade

A sign only works on people who drive past it. A website works on people who are already looking for you. Here's how many times a month people in the US search for these, from Google Ads data (12-month average, November 2025 to October 2026):

SearchSearches per month
pressure washing near me135,000
house painters near me135,000
landscaping near me110,000
junk removal near me110,000
lawn care near me90,500
window cleaning near me74,000
gutter cleaning near me49,500
pool service near me40,500

That's one phrase per trade. It adds up locally too: in Chatham County, Georgia (Savannah), searches for pressure washing and power washing run about 690 a month.

Plenty of small businesses still aren't in that race. Clutch's 2025 survey of 406 US small business owners found that "17% of small businesses still don't have a website."

If you don't have a website, none of those searchers can find you, no matter how many signs you have out. For the basics of showing up, see our guide to SEO basics for small businesses.

Make your signs work harder: put your website on them

You don't have to pick one. A sign with your website and a QR code on it does more than a sign with just a phone number:

  • Not everyone is ready to call from the car. A QR code or web address lets them look you up later, when they're ready.
  • Your website shows what an 18x24 sign can't: before-and-after photos, the areas you serve, your reviews, and your prices or a quote form.
  • A quote form takes leads at 10 p.m. while you're asleep. You call them back in the morning.

One LawnSite member who added a QR code to their signs put it this way:

"It also contains a QR code that directs people to our website. Well worth the money spent on the signs." And: "I watched people pull up and get out of their car and take a pic of the sign."

Signs get you noticed. Your website is where the person who noticed you becomes a lead.

The bottom line

  • Bandit signs: about 15 signs, about $45 and about 3 hours of your time for 2.5 calls (about $18 a call), and the signs disappear.
  • A website on Vibe Otter: $34 and 24 minutes to build for 2.5 leads in the first month on average ($13.60 a lead), and it keeps working.
  • Best of both: keep your signs, and put your website and a QR code on every one.

Get your site up on Vibe Otter for $34 a month, then put the address and a QR code on your next batch of signs. Still deciding between a Facebook page and a website? Read Website vs. Facebook Page.

Where these numbers come from

  • Sign prices: 15 bulk orders reported by lawn care, window cleaning and pressure washing owners and by sign sellers on LawnSite, WindowCleaner.com, the Pressure Washing Institute forum and Reddit, 2009 to 2024. Median $2.99 a sign; mean $2.92; range $0.89 to $5.25.
  • Calls from signs: the 8 reports in the table above, every one we found in which a service business owner gave both the number of signs and the number of calls or leads. Together that's 67 calls from 396 signs, or about 2.5 calls per 15 signs. These are owners' own reports, not a controlled study. We didn't find a measured study of bandit sign response.
  • Website leads: Vibe Otter platform data, the average number of submitted leads in the first month across 3,000+ small business websites.
  • Time: the website figure is the average time the owners in our 3,000+ site sample took to build their own site on Vibe Otter (24 minutes). The sign figure is our estimate of how long it takes to drive around a town putting out 15 signs (about 3 hours).
  • Search volumes: Google Ads keyword data via DataForSEO, United States and Chatham County, Georgia, 12-month average November 2025 to October 2026.